Donna M Carroll
“On July 1, 2020, my brother and I stopped into Gus’s for a mid day lunch, not having been to lunch inside, in so long during this pandemic.
How pleasingly surprised and delighted we both were with the outstanding got lunch of a famous Gus’ meatloaf dinner for David and Pigs in a blanket for me. Each entree fittingly served with delicious hot mashed potatoes and a vegetable.
Needless to say, the standard of excellence from the kitchen and service staff was excellent. Indeed, we shall be going back for more delicious meals. Gus’s has been in business for 4 generations, and their standards for excellence remain still superior. Thank you for continuous quality cuisine and service👍👍❤️”
“I grew up in New Windsor and our family went to Gus’s regularly. It was always my favorite restaurant. It’s been decades since I lived in New York and I don’t know if I’ll ever get back there, but I still crave Gus’s cooking, especially the dressing/stuffing they make for their roasted duck and turkey. I’ve tried to recreate it many times, but I’ve always failed. Nobody has ever made stuffing like Gus’s….and the rest of their food was fantastic too! I have such great memories of Gus’s!”
“Never disappointed. Great bratwurst, Smoked porkChop, Scnitzel, red cabbage, Sauerkraut, meat loaf, even the burgers are great.
Anxious to try Sauerbraten. See you soon”
“Gus’ Tavern is a warm and friendly place to enjoy wonderful, hearty food and drink and, if you like, some lively discussion! It’s our favorite place to go! Cheers!”
Jodi A. Zaback Gaudioso
“Gus’s Tavern is a family run restaurant. Love the family, and the staff. The food is impeccable! You will NOT get this quality from any other restaurant. Thank you for bringing me into your family seasonally…. I have really learned to love you all so very much. I truly hope folks realize the quality of food they getting, and want to patronize and support your wonderful family restaurant. Thank you from the bottom of my heart… xo”
“Once Again, Last night the Prime Rib was Nothing Short of HEAVENLY…See Ya Next Time – RMc”
Susanne Valois Giannotti
“I had such a great time last night at Gus’s Tavern…the service was excellent and the prime rib was delicious…cooked to perfection!”
“Had the best TWIN Lobster tails.. perfectly cooked there.. and my friend had a custom cut -very thick PRIME RIB.. that was as huge! go there .. very homey”
“When I worked in New Windsor, this was my favorite place for lunch. I never knew that they serves other food than meatloaf as that was all I ever ordered . Their meatloaf sandwiches were legendary, the best in the world.”